“That study distorts the reality – said Mr Mehrtens - as it suggests that the adoption of the so called Ecocombies, or Mega Trucks, would nearly be a criminal gesture. It’s a shame that in order to talking of trucks whose maximum length is 25.25 metres, the study includes pictures of trucks long more than 50 metres, that are used in Australia and whose introduction in Europe has never been on any agenda”.
“ECG has nothing against rail freight transport, rather the contrary – he added -. In fact ECG members do operate more than 16,000 rail wagons, but the “Mega Trucks versus Rail Freight study?” does manipulate the facts”. Ecocombies, or “Monster Trucks” as they are labelled in the study whose aim is to lobby the European Commission, are 25.25 metres long and are commonly used in Sweden and Finland. Their introduction is being considered in Germany; they are being tested in The Netherlands.
The study suggests that the adoption of Ecocombies would result in a modal shift, worsening road congestion. It also maintains that heavier trucks would imply a higher consumption of the infrastructures and therefore the need of higher infrastructure investments. Also the level of safety on the roads would worsen, according to the study. “None of these elements are true nor can be proved - explained Mr Mehrtens - Let’s see why: Congestion and Modal Shift: Ecocombies will not have any effect of road congestion nor they will imply any modal shift. In fact everywhere in Europe the real problem is the dramatic shortage of truck drivers. Number f drivers is on a constant decrease and recently, such a shortage has been worsened by the adoption of the European Working Time Directive. There could not be any modal shift to the detriment of the rail because there are not enough drivers even to drive the existing number of trucks. If Ecocombies are introduced, there will not be more trucks on the roads, rather the contrary. Furthermore, their introduction would just help to maintain the existing level of freight transported by road. This is a necessity in order to avoid a slowdown of the European Economy.
Investments in infrastructures: Tests carried out in many countries shows
that Ecocombies have not any negative impact on the roads. Despite a higher
payload, Ecocombies are equipped with more axels and therefore their weight per
axel is equal or even minor to that of normal trucks. It has to be underlined
that in most cases, where the size of goods prevails on the weight, including
the automotive industry – fully loaded Eurocombies would not even reach the
maximum weight of the trucks currently in use. Ecocombies doesn’t destroy
Road Safety: Where the 25.25 metres long trucks are used, the number of road
incidents long trucks are involved into is not higher then in countries where
the maximum length of trucks is 18.75 metres. Additional, specific training for
drivers of Ecocombies can be introduced, as it is the case in The Netherlands.
Environment: The introduction of Ecocombies would cut the consuption of fuel and
therefore reduce the level of CO2 emission. Their use would support the European
Union’s effort to achieve the CO2 emission target.
“Let’s be clear on this – concluded Mr Mehrtens -: ECG would like to see more freight moved onto the railways. On the other hand, it’s impossible to ignore the capacity problems the European railway network suffers of: like it or not, in the foreseable future the rail will not be the backbone of European freight transport. And it shuld be clear to everybody that no single mode of transport can solve the trasport problems of Europe”.
Established in 1997, ECG represents more than 2/3rds of the European Finished Vehicles Logistics industry. ECG Members operate in the field of outbound logistics for the Automotive sector, including quality control at the end of the assembly line, storage in special compounds, transport in all modalities – rail, road and sea – de-waxing Pre-Delivery Inspections (PDI), customising, workshop activities and the refurbishing of former fleet vehicles. ECG has 87 members from 24 countries, which last year recorded an aggregated turnover in excess of 12 billion Euros. Members handle about 40 million cars per year with over 53,000 direct employees. In terms of equipment, the ECG members operate 18,000 trucks, 16,000 rail wagons, about 230 ships; 28 river barges; 450 compounds; 110 port terminals; more than 64 million square metres of Car parks; about one million square metres of workshops.